Skip to main content

Back

Eminem v Swim Shady | Who’s Being Shady?

Eminem
Eminem v Swim Shady

By Shania Amolik | Associate and Co-Authored by Tahlia Miller-Dietrich | Paralegal

Recently, the Sydney-based brand, Swim Shady, was pushed into the spotlight after a lengthy trade mark battle with the rapper, Eminem.

Swim Shady, a retailer of beach towels, umbrellas and apparel, was successful in its application to cancel aspects of Eminem’s trade mark registrations for “Shady” and “Shady Limited” on the grounds of non-use. This marks a significant win in the brand’s long-running dispute with the rapper.

The non-use application filed by Swim Shady was a counter-move after Eminem’s team opposed the brand’s trade mark application on the basis that “Swim Shady” was confusingly similar to the rapper’s registered marks.

Swim Shady’s core argument was that Eminem had not genuinely used his “Shady” and “Shady Limited” marks in Australia for certain goods they were registered for, meaning he could not rely on these registrations to block others. Under trade mark law, registration alone is not enough to maintain protection; trade marks must be actively used in the marketplace, or they can be vulnerable to removal.

Reasons for the decision:

The reasons for the decision included:

  • As an oversight, Eminem’s representatives had not registered “Slim Shady” as a trade mark in Australia until after Swim Shady had launched.
  • “Shady” was almost exclusively used alongside other elements such as “I’m the Real Slim Shady” rather than as a standalone mark of origin.
  • During the relevant period, “Shady” was not genuinely used in Australia for certain registered goods such as clothing, footwear or bags.
  • Eminem had not exercised a sufficient level of control over the use; rather, the merchandise was sold through his record label.
  • Only three recent sales of “Shady” merchandise to Australian customers could be proven.

The Effect of the decision: 

The IP Australia Adjudicator held that the “Shady” and “Shady Limited” marks are to be removed from the Register for certain goods including trunks and travelling bags, pouches, sports bags, umbrellas, parasols, clothing and headgear.

Eminem has filed to appeal this decision.

Share: